ugh! someone asks for concrit and I give it, and they continue to make the same damn errors in future chapters/stories.
The errors aren't necessarily minor ones either. Misspelling a person's name or a city. Those are things that can be "jarring" to readers and I only point them out bc the author says they don't have a beta and they want concrit.
The errors aren't necessarily minor ones either. Misspelling a person's name or a city. Those are things that can be "jarring" to readers and I only point them out bc the author says they don't have a beta and they want concrit.
why didn't anyone tell me?
Jul. 4th, 2012 10:46 pmapparently I suck at research.
( comment I got )
Initially I was just going to ignore it, because no one has ever said that anything was incorrect before, but then I thought maybe I did miss stuff, so I asked the person to let me know what was incorrect so that I could fix it.
eta 1: for those familiar with Hawaii, what is kalabash? I was told that Kalakaua Aunties was supposed to be kalabash aunties? umm what?
eta 2: I learned something new. Kalabash is a term used to describe family that isn't blood family. Kono's Auntie's would be kalabash family to Steve/Danny and baby
( comment I got )
Initially I was just going to ignore it, because no one has ever said that anything was incorrect before, but then I thought maybe I did miss stuff, so I asked the person to let me know what was incorrect so that I could fix it.
eta 1: for those familiar with Hawaii, what is kalabash? I was told that Kalakaua Aunties was supposed to be kalabash aunties? umm what?
eta 2: I learned something new. Kalabash is a term used to describe family that isn't blood family. Kono's Auntie's would be kalabash family to Steve/Danny and baby
giving writing tips to a relative novice writer. I have no idea if my tips are any good, but this person found me on FF.net and I'm so desperately trying to keep her from following so many of the writers on there.
So far, my favorite tip that I've given her is:
I've had some reading experiences where I was into the story, but then the characters began speaking in ways they wouldn't or using words that leave me scratching my head going "o.O whut?!" so then I look up the word and it's like why not just use the "dumb" version of that same word? This isn't some technical university book.
I really hope everything I tell her makes sense and helps her. what I've read of her story so far (all ~800 words of it) has the potential to be a pretty good story.
So far, my favorite tip that I've given her is:
Word length is your choice. You don't want to fall into the habit of using words that the characters wouldn't use (on the show) or that you wouldn't use. Also, there's no use in using a $4 word when a $2 word will do. What I mean by that is, big words that make people have to think or look up what they mean (unless they're in another language) doesn't make for a pleasant reading experience.
I've had some reading experiences where I was into the story, but then the characters began speaking in ways they wouldn't or using words that leave me scratching my head going "o.O whut?!" so then I look up the word and it's like why not just use the "dumb" version of that same word? This isn't some technical university book.
I really hope everything I tell her makes sense and helps her. what I've read of her story so far (all ~800 words of it) has the potential to be a pretty good story.